Unique White Elephant Gift Ideas Near Madison

Product List

• 2026 Pissed-off Cats Calendar

  Our ferociously funny bestselling calendar features major holidays, plus 300+ fun official occasions like: National Dress Up Your Pet Day (Jan. 14), National Pizza Day (Feb. 9), National Hug Your Cat Day (Jun. 4), and many more. It's a sassy gift that friends and family will treasure – especially if they're cat owners.11" Wide by 22" Tall (Hanging)11" Wide by 11" Tall (Unopened)Ideal for home offices, kitchens, bedroomsSturdy uncoated paperWire coil bindingImported

  Store: The Raccoon Society

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Stuff Every Cheese Lover Should Know

  Within the pages of this pocket-sized guide, you’ll find information, how-tos, and trivia for cheese lovers of all levels. Casual cheese eaters and connoisseurs alike will learn about: • How Cheese Is Made • Why Some Cheeses Melt Differently • How to Build a Festive Cheese Board for Entertaining • Pairing Cheese with Wine and Beer • How to Make Cheese at Home Plus an illustrated guide to cheese gadgets, terms every cheese lover should know, how to host a cheese tasting, how to make the ultimate grilled cheese, and much more!

  Store: Fromagination

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Holiday Bakery House Cookie Jar

  This charming cookie jar is lovingly handcrafted and hand-painted, so you might spot little air bubbles, tiny pinholes, or slight paint variations—just part of its unique ceramic charm! It features a silicone-sealed lid that keeps your treats fresh and ready to enjoy. Measuring 9.5” tall and 6.5” wide and deep, it holds up to 2 quarts of deliciousness. Hand washing is best, and it’s not microwave safe. Perfect for adding a sweet touch to your holiday kitchen!

  Store: Pageberry

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Gold Mustache Bunny Wall Accent

  Add a whimsical touch to your home decor with our unique 16.5" Gold Mustache Bunny Wall Accent. This charming piece combines playfulness with elegance, making it a perfect addition to any room that needs a little sparkle and a lot of character. Crafted from high-quality metal, ensuring durability and long-lasting beauty.  The metal is finished in a striking gold tone that radiates warmth and sophistication. 16 X 13.5 X 8

  Store: Linen & Clove

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Wooden Cat Cheese Plate

  Adorable wooden cat plate perfect for a fun mini meal or as a cute addition to a cheese board. details Hand carved Measures 10" x 6.3" Sapele, Cherry, White maple, ebony

  Store: Good Day Shop

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Party On!™ Licorice Dispenser

  Anyone who has seen the movie “Wayne’s World” has wished they had this red rope licorice dispenser in their car. Oh yes, it will be yours! Your licorice dispenser comes in a super cool gift box. Upgrade to get 3 red rope licorice strands a whopping 34" long a piece! Safe plastic knife-cutting feature! Easy to Refill! Food Safe! Fun for the whole family! Newly re-engineered flexible options for mounting! This licorice dispenser makes the perfect gift for a co-worker, friend, teenager or husband. It’s also a fun accessory for rideshare drivers, at your desk, in your locker, or even in your shower.

  Store: Motormouth

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Hot Chocolate

  Warm your soul on even the coldest of wintry nights. Melted in warm milk or hot water, this velvety shaved Colombian dark chocolate will make the chill happily go away. Logo mug not included. 16 oz bag makes about 8-10 8oz servings

  Store: Gail Ambrosius Chocolatier

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• The Soap Opera Rubber Ducks - Giant 9 Inches Tall

  Who can refuse these larger than life ducks? Make bath time a SPLASH with one of our giant rubber duck! Great to use in the bath, pool, or as a beach toy! Giant size measures approx. 9 x 10 x 7

  Store: The Soap Opera

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Sasquatch - Can Glass

  Our hand drawn illustration of Sasquatch to enjoy your favorite beverages in! This 16 oz can shaped glass is a nod to a classic soda and beer cans. Durable and (top rack) dishwasher safe. Printed in Rhinelander WI by Vital Industries.

  Store: Zip-Dang

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Poupon U Baby Onesie

  Start the toddler in your life on the path to academic success by dressing them in this onesie from America's Mustard College. Sized 12-18 months.

  Store: National Mustard Museum

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Crazy Straws

  This cascading spiral design adds a fun edge to any style with this hand-etched and patinated copper pendant and earwire.

  Store: Metric Forrest Studio

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Winter Pom Pom Beanie — Delta Beer Lab

  You’ll love this old-school cuffed beanie with pom pom top. “Delta Beer Lab” knit into the cuff with hop cone and test tube design knit into the body of the hat. Snug and warm, show off your brewery spirit all winter long!

  Store: Delta Beer Lab

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Ope Dad Hat

  Ope! Embroidered on adjustable dad hat

  Store: Wisconsin Design Team

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• madison tote

  This beautiful tote was made in collaboration for Little Luxuries by the Brooklyn company Maptote. It is made and printed in the United States. A reusable, durable cotton tote for everyday use.

  Store: Little Luxuries

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Retro 80's Vibe Wisconsin T-Shirt

  This soft jersey unisex Wisconsin t-shirt, is perfect for a woman or man and has a great Wisconsin design. It is 100% soft cotton, runs true to size and comes in a variety of colors! You will love wearing this t-shirt all over Wisconsin, with it's soft cotton feel..: 100% Soft cotton .: Light fabric .: Runs true to size

  Store: Hazel General Store

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Small Scratched Leather Journal

  Whether you're keeping a travel journal, recording daily thoughts, or sketching your imaginative creations, this mini journal is designed to be your trusted companion for all your creative and reflective endeavors. Dimensions: 4.25" x 6.25"

  Store: Lily's Mercantile and Makery

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Wisco-Mythos Print - Mendota Monster

  Original Illustration by Mike BassDigital print on 80lb cover archival stockDimensions 8x19 inches - At times playful, and at others cruel, the monster of lake Mendota toys with swimmers and sailors alike. Tickeling feet, overturning vessels and snatching away pets who paddle too far from shore.

  Store: Zip-Dang

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Tooth Plush Organ

  Once you get snuggled up with this incredibly soft plush tooth, you'll realize all your tooth fairy-tales have come true! Brush aside any doubts and sink your teeth into the fun with the tooth-rific plush pal. Our tooth plushie is guaranteed to brighten up any room and put a smile on everyone's face. It's the perfect companion for dental adventures, bedtime snuggles, and a reminder to always keep smiling. Made in Wisconsin, imported, and designed by a team of nerds. It measures 9 x 8 x 4 inches and is suitable for all ages.

  Store: Nerdbugs

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Vintage Camelot Denby Teacup and Saucer Set

  A cute little teacup set, comes complete with the saucer. Perfect for a little coffee or tea treat in the afternoon. details Set of one teacup and one saucer Approx 2.5" tall Approx 6 oz

  Store: Good Day Shop

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• The Wisconsin Native Good Vibe Mesh Trucker Hat

  We have taken our Wisconsin Native design and created a series of custom hats. We designed the Good Vibe Mesh Trucker with a stone cotton twill front panel, charcoal brim, a slate mesh back and added a few mustard and forest green details. These hats are not too high and not too low, making them perfect for those good vibe Wisconsin days. ::details:: * stone front panel // charcoal brim // slate mesh back * cotton twill // mesh back * mid profile // six panel * snapback closure * cream and forest green woven patch with

  Store: Sift and Winnow

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Wool Felt Coaster - 12 Pack

  Beautiful 100% wool felt coaster set of 12, in a rainbow of colors. All are hand-stitched with love and care. Makes a great gift! Size: 9inches

  Store: Metric Forrest Studio

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Midwest Is Best Blue T-Shirt

  Unisex Sizing Multicolor design on Heather Ice Blue T-Shirt 50% Cotton / 50% Polyester

  Store: Hazel General Store

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• The Soap Opera Large Double Wick Candle 24oz - Pleasant Pine

  Cozy evergreen forests of winter pine, balsam firs, spruce & cedars with a hint of sweet citrus make up the landscape of this rich, robust and spirited scent. Set the tone for the holidays in your home, or give as a gift! The Soap Opera's collection of candles are highly fragrant and burn clean for at least 150 hours. Lovingly crafted with lead-free wicks in the USA, these candles provide a beautiful room fragrance for the whole family to enjoy.

  Store: The Soap Opera

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Pint Glass

  Elevate your cheers with our Fortune Favors branded pint glass, ideal for any occasion. A frosty cold beer pairs perfectly with our candied pecans, and now you'll enjoy both in style! When you reach the bottom of the glass, you'll find a surprise awaits you there! 16 oz. glass Microwave safe; hand-washing recommended.

  Store: Fortune Favors

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Dino Xmas Playing Cards

  Get ready for some festive fun! Our Dino Christmas Playing Cards are a 54-card deck featuring playful, retro-inspired art of dinosaurs celebrating the holidays in a cool pastel color palette. This one-of-a-kind deck comes in a durable acrylic case, making it easy to store or take on the go. It's the perfect stocking stuffer or fun gift for any dino-loving friend or family member. How Big? 2.50" x 3.50" x 1"

  Store: Wisco Home Goods

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Wisconsin Retro Sunrise T-Shirt

  This soft jersey unisex Wisconsin t-shirt, is perfect for a women or man and is a great Wisconsin t shirt. It is 100% soft cotton.

  Store: The Regal Find

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Floating Tea Infuser

  Unlock the full flavor of your tea with our Floating Tea Infuser! Versatile and portable, this infuser fits seamlessly into any drinkware and allows you to steep your favorite tea in seconds, whether you're in the mood for a hot cup or a refreshing iced drink. Enjoy the perfect cup of tea anytime, anywhere with our innovative design.

  Store: Green Life Trading Co.

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Chocolate Truffles - 16 Piece Assortment

  Our most popular box size makes a tasteful gift: 16 of our award-winning, artisan truffles in our signature foil stamped box with coordinating ribbon. The ultimate gift for clients, customers, family and friends. Please note that there is a small surcharge for custom boxes. Truffles included in the 16-piece assortment: Exotic, Nib, Smoked Salted Caramel, Old Fashioned Kentucky Bourbon, Fromage, Passion Fruit Vanilla, Tiramisu Key Lime, Vanilla Creme Brulee, Framboise, Honey Lavender Strawberry Passion, Espresso, Red velvet, S'mores

  Store: Infusion Chocolates

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Euchre Score Keeping Board

  Hey Euchre lovers! Get ready to deal out some fun with this Wisconsin-shaped Euchre board. Crafted in Milwaukee by an awesome guy named Ben, this board is a must-have for your next game night.Made from durable Hard Maple, this board is built to last through countless hands of Euchre. It's finished with an eco-friendly coating that keeps it looking great for years. Plus, this travel board hinges open to reveal a secret compartment perfect for storing the cards and the included metal pegs. So whether you're at home or on the go, you'll always be ready for a game. How Big?

  Store: Wisco Home Goods

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Tasty Trio Gift Pack 8oz

  A SYMPHONY OF ENCHANTED FLAVORS! The wondrous sampler pack, a gateway to the world of Fortune Favors. An offering both to those new to our realm and cherished devotees alike. Within, you shall discover a treasure trove of extraordinary candied pecans, each vying for your senses' affection: The Classic, a dance of sweet and salty; The Spicy, kissed by the fiery breath of chilies; and The Everything, woven with the secrets of garlic, onion, poppy, and sesame. **Please note: This pack DOES NOT include a box or gift-wrapping. For pre-boxed packs, check out the 8oz Sampler Gift Pack.** California Prop 65 Information

  Store: Fortune Favors

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• The Soap Opera Gift Set - De-Stress

  We are proud to offer our staff-selected, herbal De-Stress Gift Set assortment of products specifically designed to relieve the day's stress: Aromatherapy, hydrotherapy, temperature, salts and kindly bubbles help melt the stress away. Highly recommended by all your friendly, helpful Soap Operators! De-Stress Gift Set includes: 4oz Bubble Bath, 3.4oz Face and Body Lotion, Lavender Herbal Bath Soak, Lavender Eucalyptus Shower Steamer Sachet. Find more Gift Sets HERE.

  Store: The Soap Opera

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• WI Old Fashion Gift Kit

  Bring the classic taste of Wisconsin home with the WI Old Fashioned Gift Kit! Perfect for that friend who's moved away or anyone who appreciates a perfectly crafted cocktail, this kit is more than just a gift—it's an experience.We've packed everything you need to create a classic Wisconsin Old Fashioned:- Two elegant cut glass cokctail glasses to showcase your creation.- A durable solid wood muddler for perfectly releasing the flavors of your fruit and sugar.- A bottle of Overland's Old Fashioned Mix, a rich, authentic blend that captures the essence of a true Wisconsin cocktail.Whether you prefer brandy or whiskey, sweet or sour, this kit sets the stage for a classic cocktail night. Just add your favorite spirit, and you're ready to raise a glass to good company and great memories.Cheers to the Badger State!

  Store: Wisco Home Goods

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Scalp Massager

  Elevate your shower routine with this multi-functional Silicone Scalp and Body Massager. This Massager exfoliates the scalp and increases circulation to promote hair growth and healthier skin and hair.

  Store: Green Life Trading Co.

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Heart Plush Organ

  There’s no better way to say I love you than with these one-of-a-kind heart plush toy. Cozy and adorable, this super-soft plush makes for the perfect snuggle buddy. Our heart plushie pumps laughter and comfort into post-op patients' lives and fills hospital rooms with warm fuzzies! Whether recovering from heart surgery or seeking a dose of love, this snuggly heart plushie is here to give you a big-hearted hug!

  Store: Nerdbugs

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Wisconsin State Porcelain Plate

  Bring your love of Wisconsin into the kitchen and serve up state-shaped casseroles, dips, entrees, appetizers, pies, cakes, favorite holiday dishes, family recipes, and more. Crafted in high-fire porcelain and sealed with glossy white glaze for a non-stick surface, this Wisconsin-shaped bakeware is free of all lead and toxins which means it's safe for food use in the oven, microwave, and dishwasher. Dimensions: 11.175" x 10.125" x 1.5"

  Store: Red Barn Company Store

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Dee Dee Red Mug - 10oz

  Renowned for her retro-inspired patterns, playful approach to design, and hailed by many as the 'Queen of Prints', Orla Kiely champions the very best of 1960s & 70s styling. Her signature retro style has become instantly recognisable as a household name.10oz Bone China - Hand washMade in United Kingdom

  Store: Zip-Dang

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• Wisconsin Map | Wisconsin Snowmobile Map

  Hit the trails with our meticulously hand-drawn Wisconsin Snowmobile Map, crafted by local artist Jesse. This detailed map showcases the best snowmobile routes across the state, providing an essential guide for snowmobile enthusiasts.0Measuring 17" x 11", it combines functionality with artistry, offering a comprehensive overview of Wisconsin's top snowmobiling destinations.0Perfect for planning your next adventure or as a unique Wisconsin gift, this map celebrates the thrill and beauty of Wisconsin's winter landscapes. Whether for personal use or as a thoughtful gift, this map is a must-have for anyone passionate about snowmobiling.

  Store: JNJ Gifts and More

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• lavender & eucalyptus neck wraps

  Microwavable flax seed neck wraps infused with lavender and rosemary, or eucalyptus and peppermint. Can also be stored in the freezer as an ice pack. Please note: all patterns are unique.

  Store: Little Luxuries

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin

• The Hunter Collection

  Bold flavors, smoke and spice- is your hunter naughty or nice? Curious Collection Deer Camp - Winning mix of sea salt, licorice root, ginger and Szechuan peppercorns created for hunting lodges and live fire cooking Dayboat - Versatile smoky seafood blend with bay leaf, citrus, Icelandic sea kelp and well-rounded heat Tastes Like Victory - Savory blend of sweet onions, toasted coriander and New Mexico green chilies with hints of smoke and heat Includes the spices listed above, as well as: Hotshot - Espresso and Smoked Chicken Rub

  Store: The Deliciouser

  Location: Madison, Wisconsin